The Vanishing Dream of Home Ownership
Looking for a newly built, traditional single-family home in the Seattle market? Good luck with that!
May 15, 2017
Jeanne Lang Jones
With land to build new housing becoming scarcer in the Puget Sound region, competition among builders is getting tougher.
Its like a knife fight in a phone booth, says Ken Krivanec, president of Bellevue-based Quadrant Homes.
Ultimately, the victim may be the American dream of owning a single-family home. For many in the Northwest, the likelihood of achieving that dream fades as scarce land, rising labor costs and the arrival of hundreds of thousands of newcomers drive housing prices to unprecedented levels.
In March, the median value of a single-family home in Seattle was $700,000, up from $357,000 five years ago. Prices could continue to soar as home builders struggle to find more land to add to the supply of houses in an area that records about 6,000 home sales a year but where only 3,900 new lots are added annually.
Krivanec estimates Quadrant has just over a three-year supply of finished and in-process lots on which to build houses. Charlie Conner, owner and president of Bellevue-based Conner Homes, says he has virtually no inventory of finished homes because most of the houses Conner builds are sold before they are completed. As for land, Conner says, Most of us are working on just-in-time inventory.
The squeeze on buildable lots pushes up land prices, which, along with rising construction costs, put home ownership out of reach for many young families who covet a house and a yard for their children and pets. Unable to buy houses, a growing proportion of these people remain renters and cannot build savings as the previous generations did through home ownership, says Peter Orser, chairman of the advisory board of the Runstad Center for Real Estate Studies at the University of Washington (and a former president of Quadrant Homes). For other reasons (see story on page 32) few condos are being built, so about 55 percent of all Seattle residents remain renters.
How did it happen? Its the law of supply and demand at its most draconian. Start with Washingtons Growth Management Act, which limits the areas where builders can construct new homes. Then add a robust economy that has brought as many as 415,000 new residents to the Puget Sound area since 2012, according to an analysis of drivers license data by Bothell-based Metrostudy. (Josh Brown, executive director of the Puget Sound Regional Council, says population growth during the period is closer to 294,000, but you get the picture.)
Metrostudy Regional Director Todd Britsch says the supply of buildable lots in King and Snohomish counties is historically low and he expects it will only go lower. Land available to build on has shrunk by 16,870 lots since 2009, says Britsch, who notes that King County has a 16-month supply of buildable lots while Snohomish County is at 10 months.
With buildable land harder to come by, developers find they can make more money building apartments, multifamily homes and townhouses. Last year in the Seattle-Tacoma-Bellevue metropolitan area, about 9,000 permits for single-family homes were issued, close to one-third of the total of 25,500. Its substantially less than in 2007, when permits for 12,400 single-family houses were issued nearly half of the total of 25,460 permits granted.
More and more, these new houses constitute infill construction on vacant lots and other undeveloped parcels, including many that were built after teardown of an existing home. In the year ended March 2017, says Britsch, there were about 8,000 sales of new single-family houses in the four-county Puget Sound region. Roughly a quarter were infill construction.
Also contributing to the tight housing market is an invasion of institutional investors that have purchased some 44,000 homes in the region in recent years, effectively taking those homes off the market, notes Britsch. Earlier this year, Realtor.com ranked Seattle the tightest housing market in the country, with just one of every 263 houses for sale. That represents a 13.4 percent decrease in the supply of homes for sale compared to last year.
With the imbalance between supply and demand, the median selling price for a home in King County was $560,000 earlier this year, up 8.7 percent from a year ago.
Couples interested in houses with the traditional backyard have to go farther and farther afield from where they work. And even then, there are fewer sites on the scale needed for the kind of large master-planned communities that once provided much of the single-family housing in the region.
The projects that are in the works tend to be farther away from job centers. For instance, Tehaleh, which will have 9,200 homes when completed, is south of Bonney Lake, 40 miles from Seattle more than 90 minutes by car or train. In Black Diamond, 35 miles from Seattle, The Villages propose about 3,600 single-family units and Lawson Hills about 930.
As big as these projects are, they will do little to satisfy the regions hunger for new housing. Historically, a strong master-planned community will likely sell only about 250 homes a year, Orser says.
One possible solution is more effective use of the land that is available. According to the 2014 buildable lands report, King County has an abundance of land capacity for both residential and employment growth through 2031. But finding developable land is a challenge, thanks to the Puget Sound regions hilly, soggy terrain and restrictions on development imposed by the Growth Management Act, which is designed to prevent sprawl and to preserve the regions natural beauty.
Still, the Growth Management Act also requires cities to ensure that available housing keeps pace with job growth. Better use of geo-information technology could be used to give us a more accurate assessment of buildable lots, Orser argues.
However, where land is available, it is being used more often to build communities of multifamily homes than detached single-family homes. The Puget Sound Regional Council encourages that trend by granting scarce public transit dollars to localities that promote such density. Areas of high density can be more economically connected by public transit than single-family communities, which tend to depend more heavily on automobiles.
Another option developers have is to scoop up the ugly ducklings, odd-size pieces, secondary locations or teardowns, says Holly Gardner, president of Full Scale, a new consulting pision of the Seattle-based Schuster Group. Full Scale helps clients with real estate development projects in the city.
While there is land near Woodinville and Redmond, it can be challenging to develop because the parcels often arent connected to city sewer systems and rely instead on septic tanks. Putting in new sewage systems requires new permitting and can require a major investment.
One alternative to suburbia are the infill developments in urban areas zoned for multifamily developments. There, existing homes are torn down and replaced by townhouses, duplexes and row houses. Many are tall, narrow boxes that have no yards, but intimate views of the box next door. They often compensate for the lack of space with such amenities as gourmet kitchens and spa-style bathrooms.
Were already starting to see the influence in the exurban neighborhoods where there is a lot of infill development, a lot of townhomes, says Matthew Gardner, chief economist for Windermere Real Estate in Seattle. Those homes, which can cost upward of $700,000 for a townhouse, are aimed at wealthier millennials who want a new house but dont want to travel too far for it.
They want to buy but they dont want to buy out in the suburbs, Gardner explains. They want one foot in the city close enough to get to work downtown.
This is the market Toll Brothers is targeting with developments in Bellevue, Kirkland, Redmond and Seattle on properties near good school districts and employment centers. In Seattles Queen Anne neighborhood, for example, the company is building 57 luxury townhomes on 2.5 acres it acquired from the Seattle Childrens Home. The project was reduced from 66 units after opposition from the surrounding community, a common occurrence when large in-city developments are proposed in residential areas.
Such large opportunities are rare. The supply of buildable lots is very, very constrained, says Toll Brothers pision President Kelley Moldstad. As Toll Brothers lots are developed and sold, Moldstad says the home builder will be looking for lots in the next ring out from Seattle Snoqualmie, North Bend, Renton and Bothell.
The more and more dense we get, the farther and farther we may have to drive to get that single-family house, Moldstad says.
Meanwhile, employers may be forced to follow as affordable houses continue to be pushed farther from the job centers in downtown Seattle and Bellevue.
It would not surprise me to see some of the companies that are growing in the area look at other locations, says Conner. We could see them move out to some of the edge cities that currently dont have much in terms of jobs.
The fact that we are building too few homes now and that those skew to the higher end of the market has implications for the market long term, adds Svenja Gudell, chief economist at Zillow. We will not have the natural aging of these homes to become affordable.
That means first-time buyers will be paying a higher price. And those prospective buyers, who are already paying hefty rents, may have to wait longer to save up for a more expensive first home or move farther out to a less expensive location.
If we continue at this pace, it wont be very long, maybe five years, before the median home price doubles and puts us equivalent with San Francisco today, says Orser, who also serves on the Washington State Affordable Housing Advisory Board.
Orser would like to see more condominium development along the regions light-rail system, which would give residents the option of working in an edge city or in downtown Seattle. At this point, transit-oriented development is only a rental strategy and there is very little ownership opportunity in that corridor, Orser says. One [area] thats severely lacking is condominiums, a higher-density, more affordable way to home ownership.
Development of condos, however, has been limited by regulations that make developers vulnerable to lawsuits. Consequently, while there are about 1,100 condominiums going through the permitting process for downtown high-rises many of them large enough to accommodate a family most are quite expensive. Nexus, one of a small handful of new condo developments going up in Seattle, has its units starting in the low $900,000s.
While prices are expected to continue rising by 5 to 10 percent annually for the next couple of years, most agree they will eventually outpace the ability of buyers to pay. But rather than seeing falling prices, Britsch thinks a more likely result will be a significant drop in the rate of home ownership. He predicts that if prices for single-family houses remain high, home-ownership rates could drop to 50 percent in the Seattle area during the next decade.
That figure compares to a national home-ownership rate of about 63.7 percent.
With a million new residents expected by 2040, the region will need to accommodate a wider variety of housing types and strategies to create more affordable housing from townhomes and condominiums to accessory units and cottages. Zillows Gudell hopes officials will be able to find a solution by offering incentives for certain types of construction or modifying zoning.
Holly Gardner remains optimistic. When all the factors come together, she says, there may be a big straining moment of pause where everybody just hurts for a while. Then well figure out how to get through it.
But the solution likely wont involve single-family homes. Those houses with the little gardens and the white picket fences will likely remain on the endangered species list in the Puget Sound Region well into the future.
AFTER THE DELUGE: An invasion of national firms has changed the home-building market here.
BY JEANNE LANG JONES
In 2011, as the local economy was recovering, giant home-building firms poured into the Seattle market. Among them were Richmond American Homes (Denver), Toll Brothers (Philadelphia), Henley Properties (Australia), Newland Communities (San Diego) and Lennar Corp. (Miami). They joined Shea Homes (Los Angeles) and publicly traded home builders D.R. Horton (Fort Worth) and Centex Corp. (Dallas), now owned by PulteGroup Inc. (Atlanta).
These new players quickly snapped up local home builders. Richmond American parent M.D.C. Holdings bought SDC Homes of Seattle. Toll Brothers bought Kirklands Camwest Development. Lennar bought Premier Communities of Puyallup. Henley partner, Sumitomo Forestry Group Housing, bought Bellevues Bennett Homes. These acquisitions provided the newcomers with local expertise and instant property portfolios.
To better compete, Quadrant Homes, a former Weyerhaeuser subsidiary, hired an industrial design firm in 2012 to do consumer analytics on the housing market. The research brought in some different thinking and yielded great fruit, Quadrant President Ken Krivanec says.
Krivanec relates that some well-heeled buyers were willingly paying $750,000 for a new home at a time when Quadrants average sale price was below $300,000. So the company developed a contemporary design aesthetic and decided to concentrate on the Eastside luxury home market.
Quadrant itself was acquired in 2014 by publicly traded TRI Pointe Group, which is based in the Los Angeles area and owns six premium homebuilding brands operating across eight states. Fueled by new capital, Quadrant began shopping for land from Bothell to the Renton Highlands and was able to win some very aggressive bids, says Bonnie Geers, Quadrants SVP of community development.
Quadrant also sold five properties in Seattles Columbia City neighborhood, where it once planned to build more than 100 townhomes. The properties had appreciated significantly in value. Selling the assets in Seattle let us keep our energy focused in the direction we were heading, Geers notes. Quadrant currently has three townhome sites on the Eastside in Kirkland, Newcastle and near the planned light-rail line in Bellevue.
Meanwhile, Charlie Conner, owner and president of Conner Homes in Bellevue, says his company had to become more nimble to compete against the larger home builders. At its peak in 2004, Conner Homes built about 220 homes a year. After suffering a dip in production during the recession, Conner extended its reach into the South End market and partnered with another business with significant land holdings there. The geographic expansion enabled Conner to return to a pace above 200 homes a year despite the downturn.
Conner now has a presence in seven communities, from Sammamish in the north to Edgewood and Buckley in the south.
While the business did slow in 2009, says Conner, support from its banks enabled the company to continue building throughout the recession. One advantage of being an independent home builder, Conner adds, is that he can be more creative in the type of house he builds on a particular parcel that might not fit a larger builders stock house plans.
Like Quadrant, Conner is also building townhomes. He sees them as a good alternative for empty nesters and others who dont necessarily want a big yard.
But Conner says the competition remains pretty fierce from national companies that can spread their risk across projects nationwide. People build in inflation, assuming prices will continue to go up 10 to 15 percent per year, Conner says. If you operate all over the United States in different markets, then perhaps you will gamble here and there and pay the upper price for land.
By contrast, says Conner, We have to make it work here because we are a local company.
Puyallup-based Soundbuilt Homes has also adjusted. Before the recession, Soundbuilt was doing 600 to 700 homes a year. It has scaled back production to about 200 homes annually.
All the nationals are here and its hard to get land to do that kind of number, says COO Kurt Wilson. We have to be nimble and able to do various types and sizes of projects that we may not have done 10 years ago.
Soundbuilt builds houses in King, Pierce and Thurston counties, from Renton to Gig Harbor south to Yelm. Soundbuilt also develops and sells land to national home builders when the properties dont fit into its production timeline, Wilson says. The company is working on some big projects that were acquired before or during the downturn and are being built in phases.
THE CONDO MINIMUM: New units are hard to come by and that’s not likely to change anytime soon
BY ELAINE PORTERFIELD
Seattle is awash in new luxury apartments, with tons more set to open in the next 18 months or so. But just try buying a new condominium in Seattle.
With the exception of Luma a luxury condo building on First Hill that sold out a few months after completion in 2016 virtually no condos have been built in recent years due to what local real estate experts call a perfect storm of factors. And that means an extremely tight to nonexistent supply of both new and existing condos, a blow for some first-time buyers who were relying on condominiums as an affordable entry point for home ownership.
Why is there a condo shortage? Well, it could have to do with the number of quality Seattle condo projects currently involved in lawsuits or arbitration, says Fionnuala OSullivan, managing broker and owner at Gerrard Beattie & Knapp, a Seattle real estate company. The core of the issue is the Washington Condominium Act, which includes provisions requiring developers to warranty their construction work for four years.
Basically, it comes down to the fact that anyone who builds a condo in the city will likely face some form of legal action, says Matthew Gardner, chief economist for Windermere Real Estate. To offset that likelihood, developers feel compelled to buy insurance against a lawsuit, so they choose to build apartments that can later be sold to institutional investors at a good price.
And dont expect developers to convert local apartments into condos anytime soon. The economics seldom pencil out when adding up the costs of purchasing the property, making improvements, paying taxes and covering other expenses.
You cant start repairs until the last tenant leaves, Gardner explains, so you have no revenue coming in in terms of rent, but [the mortgage] stays the same.
One rare new downtown condo development coming on the market is Nexus, a 41-story, 382-unit complex in the Denny Triangle neighborhood. Dean Jones, principal and owner of Realogics Sothebys International Realty, which represents Nexus, says such is the pent-up demand for new downtown condos that hundreds of potential buyers lined up last year, including some who spent the night waiting in line, to put down a $5,000 refundable deposit for right of first opportunity to purchase when the homes are officially released for sale.
Ben Kakimoto, a condo specialist with Keller Williams Realty, says he knows of only two other condo complexes underway at present: Gridiron in Pioneer Square, with 107 units, and Hendon Condominiums, a boutique-style development of 32 units on Phinney Ridge.
We are shocked how few condos there are [under construction], Kakimoto says. There is such a need.